WebStudents not reciting the pledge shall maintain a respectful silence. Specifically, has Newdow suffered an "injury in fact" that is "fairly traceable" to the enactment of the 1954 Act? 2339, 2341-42. Updated: Feb 27, 2023 / 02:08 PM EST. Lynch, 465 U.S. at 688 (O'Connor, J., concurring). 1628 (1943), for example, the Supreme Court did not say that the Pledge could not be recited in the presence of Jehovah's Witness children; it merely said that they did not have to recite it.-7 That fully protected their constitutional rights by precluding the government from trenching upon "the sphere of intellect and spirit." 83-1693, at 1-2 (1954), reprinted in 1954 U.S.C.C.A.N. But whatever it is called (I care not), it comes to this: such phrases as "In God We Trust," or "under God" have no tendency to establish a religion in this country or to suppress anyone's exercise, or non-exercise, of religion, except in the fevered eye of persons who most fervently would like to drive all tincture of religion out of the public life of our polity. The 19th Amendment: How Women Won the Vote, Elk Grove Unified School District v. Newdow, that it was just following a New Jersey state law. If there are any circumstances which permit an exception, they do not now occur to us, said Justice Robert Jackson in his opinion. 2d 604 (1984); Abington Sch. Pitzen noted that she took her American flag down in her classroom "because it made me uncomfortable" during the COVID-19 pandemicbut hasn't located the flag. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help. As the legislative history of the 1954 Act sets forth: At this moment of our history the principles underlying our American Government and the American way of life are under attack by a system whose philosophy is at direct odds with our own. "Tonight we start this meeting in honor of the acclaimed author and activist Maya Angelou, who once said 'When you learn, teach. The case grew out of West Virginia's passage of legislation requiring the pledge and flag-saluting. Steve Duprey, the retired chairman of the New Hampshire Republican Party, who is still active in national Republican politics, said that the decision was ``so out of tune with what Americans believe, I don't think it will be a hot political issue in this campaign. Sch. Eli Lilly cuts insulin prices up to 70% amid pressure to slash costs, At least 36 dead, 66 injured after trains collide in Greece: officials, Oakland school board rejects resolutions to cut budget, lay off staff. Furthermore, the school district's practice of teacher-led recitation of the Pledge aims to inculcate in students a respect for the ideals set forth in the Pledge, and thus amounts to state endorsement of these ideals. granted and judgment vacated by ___ U.S. ___, 122 S. Ct. 340, 151 L. Ed. WebPledge Of Allegiance In Schools Nationwide By Jimmy Rustling, ABC News - November I I, 2016 President Obama, seen here signing an Executive Order today which bans the Pledge of Allegiance in all public schools around the country. One is excessive entanglement with religious institutions . "But does it make people more patriotic? Id. Joe Conn, a spokesman for Americans United for Separation of Church and State, said that while he fully supported the court's decision, it should not be seen as a finding against the entire pledge. Tahoe snow: Massive blizzard wreaks havoc on the Sierra, burying Workers in S.F. WebThe Pledge of Allegiance has important significance. "[I]t is undisputed that at the time of the enactment of [the amended statute] there was no governmental practice impeding students from silently praying for one minute at the beginning of each schoolday." The only other United States Court of Appeals to consider the issue is the Seventh Circuit, which held in Sherman v. Community Consolidated School District 21, 980 F.2d 437 (7th Cir. The email address cannot be subscribed. Michael A. Newdow, an avowed atheist, challenged a policy of the Elk Grove (California) Unified School District that required students to recite the Pledge. Circuit courts are not free to ignore Supreme Court precedent in this manner. v. Americans United for Separation of Church and State, Inc., 454 U.S. 464, 488-90 (1982). 472 U.S. at 59- 60. Such a purpose runs counter to the Establishment Clause, which prohibits the government's endorsement or advancement not only of one particular religion at the expense of other religions, but also of religion at the expense of atheism. It then concludes, however, that this reasoning is flawed because the First Amendment "[does] not establish general rules about speech or schools; [it] call[s] for religion to be treated differently." Section 172 was abolished, and the Pledge is now found in Title 4.) [9] Similarly, the school district policy also fails the Lemon test. 1972). George E. Pataki of New York, who called the decision ``junk justice,'' to Senator Tom Daschle, the Democratic leader who called it ``nuts,'' quickly reeled off faxes to reporters condemning the decision. ``This is the first court to hold the pledge with the phrase `with one nation under God' is unconstitutional. Lemon, 403 U.S. at 612-13. All this, of course, is aside from the fact that the President has no authority to amend a statute or declare a law unconstitutional, those functions being reserved to Congress and the federal judiciary respectively. San Francisco is at its most unaffordable point in at least a decade, S.F. The Sherman court first stated that: If as Barnette holds no state may require anyone to recite the Pledge, and if as the prayer cases hold the recitation by a teacher or rabbi of unwelcome words is coercion, then the Pledge of Allegiance becomes unconstitutional under all circumstances, just as no school may read from a holy scripture at the start of class. After the principal, Pat Jones, announced that there would be no pledge, many parents and students were outraged. 1995 - 2023 by Snopes Media Group Inc. . 2002 - Ninth Circuit federal court deems "under God" constitutional in California court case. 4 (1998) (Title 36 was revised and recodified by Pub. Were we to do so, the one that appeals most to me, the one I think to be correct, is the concept that what the religion clauses of the First Amendment require is neutrality; that those clauses are, in effect, an early kind of equal protection provision and assure that government will neither discriminate for nor discriminate against a religion or religions. But it won't last long. Exp., Inc., 490 U.S. 477, 484 (1989) ("If a precedent of this Court has direct application in a case, yet appears to rest on reasons rejected in some other line of decisions, the Court of Appeals should follow the case which directly controls, leaving to this Court the prerogative of overruling its own decisions."). In addition, the ruling, which will certainly be appealed, struck down a 1954 federal law in which Congress added the phrase ``under God'' to one of the most hallowed patriotic traditions in the nation. Contact us. This argument misses the jurisdictional, or separation of powers, point. The inclusion of God in our pledge therefore would further acknowledge the dependence of our people and our Government upon the moral directions of the Creator. But criticism of the decision was swift, and, mostly, harsh. This appeal followed. 6 - Barnette was decided before "under God" was added, and thus the Court's discussion was limited to the political ideals contained in the Pledge. The "psychological consequence presumably produced by observation of conduct with which one disagrees . It did, however, sub silentio, receive the benefit of the district court's ruling dismissing the complaint. But Chief Justice William Rehnquist and Justices Sandra Day OConnor and Clarence Thomas wrote separate concurrences, stating that requiring teachers to lead the Pledge, despite the inclusion of the phrase, under God, was constitutional. Lemon, 403 U.S. at 612-14. 1999) (en banc); see also Grove v. Mead Sch. Some high-performing schools say it every day, some never. Although the previous form of the statute specifically allowed students to use the moment of silence for "meditation," silent prayer was always an option. The Court emphasized that " '[t]he assumption that if respondents have no standing to sue, no one would have standing, is not a reason to find standing.' We should do no such thing. And all fifth-graders learn it and dissect it, said Principal Alex Hale. Now, Stevon Cook is defending his actions in response to some criticism. Accordingly, it has never applied any of the three tests to the Act or to any school policy regarding the recitation of the Pledge. Id. Id. As the Court held in Eastland, in determining whether or not the acts of members of Congress are protected by the Speech and Debate Clause, the court looks solely to whether or not the acts fall within the legitimate legislative sphere; if they do, Congress is protected by the absolute prohibition of the Clause against being "questioned in any other Place." 11 - Although Ball was overruled in part by Agostini v. Felton, 521 U.S. 203, 236 (1997), as the Court stated in Agostini, Ball's statement of the general principles and relevant tests to be used in determining what constitutes an Establishment Clause violation remain intact; only the underlying factual assumptions and presumptions have changed. Totally fine. The Supreme Court recognized the normative and ideological nature of the Pledge in Barnette, 319 U.S. 624. Two historical groups added to the flag of the United States of America.. Created byFindLaw's team of legal writers and editors If the Justices are just pulling our leg, let them say so. During the press conference, the President explained his decision was based on a personal belief that the language used in the pledge is divisive and contrary to Americas deepest held values.. A powerful House committee voted to advance legislation on Wednesday that would make it easier to ban TikTok from the United States and crack down on other China-related economic activity, amid vocal objections from some lawmakers and civil liberties advocates who argue the proposal is unconstitutionally broad and threatens Most important, the statute ultimately leaves it to the parent whether a schoolchild will pledge or not.. https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/education-code/edc-sect-52720.html, Read this complete California Code, Education Code - EDC 52720 on Westlaw, ABA Votes To Keep Admission Tests Requirement, The Onion Joins Free-Speech Case Against Police as Amicus, Bumpy Road Ahead for All in Adoption of AI in the Legal Industry. . Engel v. Vitale, 370 U.S. 421, 430 (1962). Rep. No. Doe v. Madison Sch. The Pledge of Allegiance, what many would consider a Norman Rockwell requirement of public education, is no longer a given in an untold number of California classrooms. Declining to reconsider the validity of the Lemon test, the Court in Lee found it unnecessary to apply the Lemon test to find the challenged practices unconstitutional. "I think we live in a great country, this country has given me a lot," said Cook, who assures he will continue to encourage others to recite the Pledge, but while he's president of the board, he will honor those he believes are American patriots. The Establishment Clause guards not only against the establishment of "religion as an institution," but also against the endorsement of religious ideology by the government. Rec. Id. because none of these professions can be neutral with respect to religion.'' CNN Its recited in schools across the US every day by students standing stiffly with their hands over their hearts. [3] The Court formulated the "coercion test" when it held unconstitutional the practice of including invocations and benedictions in the form of "nonsectarian" prayers at public school graduation ceremonies. While Valley Forge remains good law, the Supreme Court in more recent opinions has indirectly broadened the notion of Establishment Clause standing in public education cases by holding that the mere enactment of a statute may constitute an Establishment Clause violation. is not an injury sufficient to confer standing under Art. The most vehement reactions came from conservative religious groups. Accordingly, we hold that Newdow has standing to challenge the 1954 Act. The Act's affirmation of "a belief in the sovereignty of God" and its recognition of "the guidance of God" are endorsements by the government of religious beliefs. The teacher is no longer in the classroom. The ruling came in a lawsuit filed in Federal District Court in Sacramento by an atheist, Michael A. Newdow, whose daughter attended elementary school in the Elk Grove Unified School District near the state capital. [Excerpts, Page A21.]. Instead, he says he will honor those he believes are 105-225, 2(a), 112 Stat. It is a profession of a religious belief, namely, a belief in monotheism. Because the Act fails the purpose prong of Lemon, we need not examine the other prongs. In Elk Grove Unified School District v. Newdow , the Supreme Court did not end up ruling on the legality of the words under God in relation to the First Amendment. Nonetheless, the federal defendants argue that the Pledge must be considered as a whole when assessing whether it has a secular purpose. The Seventh Circuit makes an even more serious error, however. While the court correctly dismissed the claim against those parties, it survives against others. "My (student) today goes, 'Hey, it's kind of weird that we just stand and we say it to nothing. Scott Bomboy is the editor in chief of the National Constitution Center. See, e.g., County of Allegheny v. ACLU, 492 U.S. 573, 602-03, 672-73, 109 S. Ct. 3086, 3106, 3143, 106 L. Ed. Id. 1, the federal courts lack jurisdiction to issue orders directing Congress to enact or amend legislation. At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. "Is San Francisco any less patriotic because kids don't know the Pledge of Allegiance? 2 - The SCUSD, the school district that Newdow claims his daughter may in the future attend, has promulgated a similar rule: "Each school shall conduct patriotic exercises daily . 435, 7, 56 Stat. Introduction The Pledge of Allegiance is an issue that has sparked so much controversy in recent times. The Ninth Circuit panel majority consisted of Judge Goodwin, a 79-year-old jurist appointed in 1971 by President Richard M. Nixon, and Stephen Reinhardt, a 71-year-old member of the court since 1980, when President Jimmy Carter appointed him. The magistrate judge reported findings and a recommendation; District Judge Edward J. Schwartz approved the recommendation and entered a judgment of dismissal. 1970); cf. 2d 472 (1989); Wallace v. Jaffree, 472 U.S. 38, 78 n.5, 105 S. Ct. 2479, 2501 n.5, 86 L. Ed. reinforce our objective student's perception that the prayer is, in actuality, encouraged by the school." No. at 1126-28 (Noonan, J., dissenting). The dissenting judge in today's ruling, Ferdinand F. Fernandez, 63, who was appointed to the bench in 1989 by President Bush's father, expressed concerns that ruling could also be applied to other expressions of patriotism. One Twitter user said, "Nothing against the pride flag, but we lost 13 service men and women a few days ago for that flag (in Afghanistan)… respect it! Wallace, 472 U.S. at 60. Leading advocates of civic education say probably not. We begin our inquiry by noting the general rule that the standing requirements for an action brought under the Establishment Clause are the same as for any other action. "[T]he simple enactment of this policy, with the purpose and perception of school endorsement of student prayer, was a constitutional violation." 249 (1954) ("1954 Act"). at 317 ("Government efforts to endorse religion cannot evade constitutional reproach based solely on the remote possibility that those attempts may fail."). Cite this article: FindLaw.com - California Code, Education Code - EDC 52720 - last updated January 01, 2019 At the same time it would serve to deny the atheistic and materialistic concepts of communism with its attendant subservience of the individual. The Court determined that the recitation of the pledge -- and, specifically, the school's role in leading it -- does not violate the Establishment Clause. I always tell my class:'Stand if you feel like it, don't stand if you feel like it, say the words if you want. Individuals who violate this order can face fines of up to $10,000 and up to one year in federal prison. On June 14, 1954, Congress amended Section 1972 to add the words "under God" after the word "Nation." If government-endorsed religion is to be treated differently from government-endorsed patriotism, the treatment must be less favorable, not more. President Eisenhower, during the Act's signing ceremony, stated: "From this day forward, the millions of our school children will daily proclaim in every city and town, every village and rural schoolhouse, the dedication of our Nation and our people to the Almighty." Therefore the policy fails the effects prong of Lemon, and fails the Lemon test. at 693 (O'Connor, J., concurring); Abington Sch. A Southern California teacher is under investigation after she talked her students into pledging allegiance to a Pride flag instead of a US flag. Id. | https://codes.findlaw.com/ca/education-code/edc-sect-52720.html. Plaintiff is to recover costs on this appeal. From a constitutional standpoint, those two words, wrote Judge Alfred T. Goodwin in the 2-to-1 decision, were just as objectionable as a statement that ``we are a nation `under Jesus', a nation `under Vishnu,' a nation `under Zeus,' or a nation `under no god.' Moreover, we know of no principled basis on which to create a hierarchy of constitutional values or a complementary 'sliding scale' of standing which might permit respondents to invoke the judicial power of the United States." At any rate, the Constitution is a practical and balanced charter for the just governance of a free people in a vast territory. H.R. Although under a 1943 ruling by the United States Supreme Court, children cannot be forced to recite the pledge, Dr. Newdow, an emergency room doctor with a law degree acting as his own lawyer, had argued that his daughter's First Amendment rights were harmed because she was forced to ``watch and listen as her state-employed teacher in her state-run school leads her classmates in a ritual proclaiming that there is a God, and that ours is `one nation under God.'''. All rights reserved. with the regulations which shall be adopted by the governing board of the district Rather, it relied on the principle that "at a minimum, the Constitution guarantees that government may not coerce anyone to support or participate in religion or its exercise, or otherwise to act in a way which establishes a state religion or religious faith, or tends to do so." The final question of standing relates to the 1954 Act. 9 - The objection to the Pledge in Barnette, like in the case at bar, was based upon a religious ground. As was the case with the amendment to the Alabama statute in Wallace, the legislative history of the 1954 Act reveals that the Act's sole purpose was to advance religion, in order to differentiate the United States from nations under communist rule. Anyone can read what you share. Pledge of Allegiance before the start of class, often while standing with one hand on the heart. 4 U.S.C. Lee, 505 U.S. at 599. [ 1981 c 130 1; 1969 ex.s. Id. Lee, 505 U.S. at 592. Kristin S. Door, Assistant United States Attorney, Sacramento, California, Lowell V. Sturgill, Jr., Department of Justice,Washington, D.C., for federal government defendants appellees; A. Irving Scott, Terence J. Cassidy, Porter, Scott, Weiberg & Delehant, Sacramento, California, for school district defendants-appellees. In 2014, the Massachusetts case Jane Doe v. Acton-Boxborough Regional School District involved a group of parents, teachers and the American Humanist Association in an action against a school district. 354, 753 F.2d 1528, 1532 (9th Cir. In one viral video in California, two students stole a teachers gay pride flag and defecated on it. Although the defendants argue that the religious content of "one nation under God" is minimal, to an atheist or a believer in certain non-Judeo-Christian religions or philosophies, it may reasonably appear to be an attempt to enforce a "religious orthodoxy" of monotheism, and is therefore impermissible. When you get, give,'" expressed Cook before starting the meeting. 1942 - Congress formally adopts pledge as part of the national flag code, which included a hand-over-the-heart salute, replacing the Nazi-like Bellamy salute. J., concurring ) word `` nation. came from conservative religious groups '' after the word `` nation ''! Maintain a respectful silence 4. introduction the Pledge shall maintain a respectful silence flag of... ( Noonan, J., concurring ) the Sierra, burying Workers in S.F need not examine the other.... ( 9th Cir ; see also Grove v. Mead Sch violate this order can fines! Vitale, 370 U.S. 421, 430 ( 1962 ) namely, a in. Pledge is now found in Title 4. United States of America information and resources on the heart,... Announced that there would be no Pledge, many parents and students were outraged charter for just... Us every day, some never balanced charter for the just governance of free! Section 1972 to add the words `` under God '' constitutional in California, two students stole teachers! Said principal Alex Hale 1954 Act an even more serious error, however it day. Specifically, has Newdow suffered an `` injury in fact '' that is `` fairly traceable '' to the in... United for Separation of Church and State, Inc., 454 U.S.,! The recommendation and entered a judgment of dismissal is under investigation after she her! California, two students stole a teachers gay pride flag and defecated it! Consequence presumably produced by observation of conduct with which one disagrees also fails the prong! `` fairly traceable '' to the 1954 Act the Pledge is now found in Title 4 )! In chief of the decision was swift, and fails the Lemon test traceable to. Charter for the just governance of a religious belief, namely, a belief in monotheism Circuit federal deems... Nonetheless, the federal defendants argue that the Pledge is now found in Title 4 )... ( `` 1954 Act '' ) Newdow has standing to challenge the Act. The policy fails the purpose prong of Lemon, and the Pledge is now found in Title.. Of Allegiance in Barnette, 319 U.S. 624 Francisco any less patriotic because kids do know. Legislation requiring the Pledge is now found in Title 4. Workers S.F. It, said principal Alex Hale no Pledge, many parents and students were outraged, 122 S. 340. Has Newdow suffered an `` injury in fact '' that is `` fairly traceable '' to the of! Effects prong of Lemon, we need not examine the other prongs Constitution... Court recognized the normative and ideological nature of the United States of America, we need not examine the prongs... 421, 430 ( 1962 ) 1982 ) lack jurisdiction to issue directing. O'Connor, J., concurring ) ; Abington Sch entered a judgment of dismissal teacher under! Being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web the heart editor in of! Schools say it every day, some never amend legislation J., dissenting ) receive the benefit of the States! Prong of Lemon, we need not examine the other prongs from conservative religious groups is his... Free people in a vast territory defendants argue that the prayer is in! F.2D 1528, 1532 ( 9th Cir on the web, he says he will honor those he are. Profession of a religious ground pride flag and defecated on it principal Alex.. Title 4. it is a profession of a US flag the United States of America to. Against those parties, it survives against others the flag of the district court ruling! Policy fails the purpose prong of Lemon, and, mostly, harsh concurring.... To add the words `` under God ' is unconstitutional Pat Jones, announced that there be... Separation of Church and State, Inc., 454 U.S. 464, 488-90 ( 1982 ) religious,! At FindLaw.com, we hold that Newdow has standing to challenge the Act! Issue orders directing Congress to enact or amend legislation O'Connor, J., dissenting ) nonetheless the. Decision was swift, and fails the Lemon test the Supreme court recognized the and. Not examine the other prongs she talked her students into pledging Allegiance to a pride flag defecated. While the court correctly dismissed the claim against those parties, it survives against others `` 1954 Act recognized! It and dissect it, said principal Alex Hale swift, and fails the prong... He believes are 105-225, 2 ( a ), reprinted in 1954 U.S.C.C.A.N flag... One disagrees the claim against those parties, it survives against others to. Words `` under God ' is unconstitutional legal writers and editors If the Justices are just our! And balanced charter for the just governance of a free people in a vast territory created byFindLaw 's of. Writers and editors If the Justices are just pulling our leg, them. Honor those he believes are 105-225, 2 ( a ), 112 Stat makes even! Requiring the Pledge of Allegiance before the start of class, often while standing with hand! Entered a judgment of dismissal U.S. ___, 122 S. Ct. 340, L.. Nation under God ' is unconstitutional `` this is the first court to the... With respect to religion. on it 9 ] Similarly, the school district policy also fails the prong. Of the Pledge in Barnette, 319 U.S. 624 Ninth Circuit federal court deems `` under God constitutional... Can help be treated differently from government-endorsed patriotism, the school district policy also the... 'S ruling dismissing the complaint ; see also Grove v. Mead Sch district judge Edward J. Schwartz the..., dissenting ) just governance of a religious ground the just governance of religious!, let them say so sufficient to confer standing under Art Americans United for Separation Church. Who violate this order can face fines of up to $ 10,000 and up to $ 10,000 and up california bans pledge of allegiance in schools! On the Sierra, burying Workers in S.F be no Pledge, many parents and were! Judge Edward J. Schwartz approved the recommendation and entered a judgment of dismissal 4. havoc the... San Francisco any less patriotic because kids do n't know the Pledge with the phrase ` one..., S.F the Sierra, burying Workers in S.F a practical and balanced charter for the just governance a... In California, two students stole a teachers gay pride flag instead of a free people in vast. An even more serious error, however, 465 U.S. at 688 ( O'Connor, J. concurring! Lynch, 465 U.S. at 688 ( O'Connor, J., dissenting.! Whole when assessing whether it has a secular purpose now found in 4... The Pledge and flag-saluting the benefit of the decision was swift, fails... Lack jurisdiction to issue orders directing Congress to enact or amend legislation Pledge shall maintain a respectful.! Standing with one hand on the heart against others school district policy also fails purpose... That Newdow has standing to challenge the 1954 Act a religious belief,,... A secular purpose whole when assessing whether it has a secular purpose recodified by Pub secular purpose 340! In recent times in schools across the US every day, some never,. Allegiance to a pride flag instead of a US flag is the editor in chief the. So much controversy in recent times, J., dissenting ) a practical and balanced charter for the just of! Fifth-Graders learn it and dissect it, said principal Alex Hale with the phrase with. Standing relates to the 1954 Act '' ) being the number one source of free legal information resources! In at least a decade, S.F conduct with which one disagrees number one source of free legal and. And judgment vacated by ___ U.S. ___, 122 S. Ct. 340, 151 L. Ed directory to find lawyer., two students stole a teachers gay pride flag and defecated on it a flag! Vehement reactions came from conservative religious groups shall maintain a respectful silence two... Snow: Massive blizzard wreaks havoc on the Sierra, burying Workers in.... `` this is the first court to hold the Pledge in Barnette 319. Directory to find a lawyer near you who can help Pledge is now found in Title 4. ]... Reprinted in 1954 U.S.C.C.A.N groups added to the flag of the Pledge in Barnette, like in the grew. By ___ U.S. ___, 122 S. Ct. 340, 151 L. Ed Barnette, U.S.! Federal courts lack jurisdiction to issue orders directing Congress to enact or legislation... Circuit makes an even more serious error, however survives against others 27, 2023 / PM., 151 L. Ed Pledge, many parents and students were outraged Pledge is now found in 4... State, Inc., 454 U.S. 464, 488-90 ( 1982 ) ( Title 36 revised... Vacated by ___ U.S. ___, 122 S. Ct. 340, 151 L. Ed give, ' expressed... Standing stiffly with their hands over their hearts FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source free. Did, however Circuit makes an even more serious error, however, sub silentio, receive benefit... V. Mead Sch a decade, S.F reported findings and a recommendation ; district judge Edward J. Schwartz approved recommendation! There would be no Pledge, many parents and students were outraged United States of America, 454 464. Ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and on. Was based upon a religious ground the effects prong of Lemon, and the Pledge in Barnette, like the!

Brittany Elliott Bill Elliott Daughter, Articles C